7.0 Some Questions and Answers
Q: Can I do this cheaply?
A: No, relative to a similar size fish-only tank. (See cost estimate section)
Q: What if all I want to keep is Anemones?
A: Water quality requirements drop some (Nitrates should remain under 20ppm NO3-). Lighting requirements are similar to full-reef tanks.
* The keeping of clownfish hosting anemones is coming under some justified ethical review. In nature these anemones are very long lived and have low successful reproduction rates. This compounds with typically short
(a couple of years vs. potentially hundreds in the wild) lifetimes of captive anemones.
Q: What are good test kits?
A: Tetra Hardness
* Hach Calcium, Iron, Phosphate - (303) 669-3050
* LaMotte Nitrate, PhosphateHach Test kit details: Calcium: Cat No 1457-01, Model HA-4P, $47.50, 100 test
Dilute your sample 2:1 (Distilled:Saltwater).
Each drop of titrant will equal 24mg/l of Ca++
Dilution saves titrant, and yields clearer results
with sufficient accuracy.
Iron: Cat No 22993-00, Model IR-21, $57.50, 100 test
* Very important if Macro Algae growth of primary interest.
Phosphate: Cat No 2248-00, Mdl PO-19, $54.50, 100 test
This test is 2.5 times more sensitive than the LaMotte test. The Hach is rated down to 0.02ppm, the LaMotte 0.05ppm.
Silica: Cat No 22550-00, Model SI-7, $72.50, 100 test
* Not tested by any of the authors of this FAQ. Mentioned due to its availability and track record of Hach kits.
Q: What about cheaper kits?
A: Kordon Ammonia, Nitrite, low-end Nitrate not bad for gross measurement,
* will need LaMotte Nitrate after water is in proper pollution range.
Q: Which Salt Mix is best?
A: Instant Ocean works for many. Reef Crystal has had reported problems. Tropic Marin recommended by some. Coralife dissolves fast, can sometimes be found cheap, but is suspected of having higher borate concentrations than natural seawater.
* Note that all 50 gallon bags of salt are not the same. Instant Ocean bags weigh in at 16lbs each, Coralife at 14.5lbs each. There is no magic here, at a given temperature, a bag of IO will make a solution of higher specific gravity (or more gallons at the same specific gravity) than a bag of Coralife will.
Q: How do I get rid of algae in my reef tank?
A: There are three types of undesirable "algae" that commonly grow in reef tanks: long green strands of hair algae, short fuzzy green turf algae, and brown or red slime algae. Some people also consider fleshy macro alga, such as Caulerpa, to be a pest as they can overgrow and
choke out corals. Desirable alga are the calcareous ones, both encrusting coralline alga in pink, purple, white, yellow, maroon and brown, and larger calcareous alga such as Halimeda. Some believe that any Macroalgae (Caulerpa, Halimeda, etc.) do not belong in Reef tanks.
"Slime" alga is actually cyanobacteria, not an alga. While its growth is often taken as a sign of poor water quality, its occurrence is part of the normal succession of a developing aquarium. It is uncommon for it not to occur at some point. With patience it will go away all on its own, but there are some things you can do to expedite the situation and help prevent it from recurring:
Chevron and Mimic tangs are known for having an appetite for cyanobacteria, as are baby queen conch and some hermit crabs. Adding such creatures should help a lot. So will inoculating the tank with some substrate from an established tank that is slime algae free. Apparently such tanks harbor microfauna that consume or otherwise compete with the cyanobacteria. By inoculating a tank experiencing the problem with a small handful of substrate (a few tablespoons full will do) from an established tank without the problem, chances are good that you will get a starter colony of the desired microfauna. Use of activated carbon, strong protein skimming, active mechanical removal, strong water currents, and use of kalkwasser, will also help control its growth. As with most things associated with reef tanks, don't expect overnight results.
We STRONGLY recommend AGAINST the use of ANY antibiotics, such as Maracyn, in reef tanks. As a reef aquarist, you spend a lot of effort and resources to build the bio-diversity of your tank up. Use of antibiotics is in direct conflict with that goal. At best, it's a temporary setback for the cynanobacteria, which, like most bacteria, will eventually build up a resistance to the antibiotic.
The best way to deal with hair and turf algae is not to let it grow to begin with. Keep the tank dark while it is initially cycling. Keep nitrates and phosphates as low as possible, and siphon out detritus. Keep herbivores in the tank. Snails (as many as 1 for every 2-3 gallons) will eat turf algae, and hair algae before it gets long. Tangs (especially Chevron, Mimic, and Yellow) and many small blennies will eat many forms of algae. If the tank does become overgrown, pull as much as possible out by hand. Reduce the light cycle, or if there is nothing light sensitive in the tank, leave it in darkness for a couple of weeks. Get more herbivores. Be sure to siphon out their droppings, which if left in the tank make great algae fertilizer. I have found that urchins can help recover an overgrown tank, although they will knock things over and eat any kind of algae, including desirable calcareous algaes. Large numbers of small hermit crabs (on the order of 1 per gallon) are very effective at removing and maintaining hair-algae free live rock - but do little for sidewalls and glass. As usual, a large bio-diversity with a mix of snails, tangs, crabs, and other herbivores will do the best job.
Two relatively new concepts are currently getting some attention in regards to hair algae control:
- micrograzers and
- long cycling
Some are beginning to believe that the small Copepods and other "meiograzers" have a substantial impact on the quantity of visible hair algae. The belief is that the hair algae is always there, it's simply mowed down by the meiograzers to the point where it's not typically visible. If this is true, then inclusion of some fish, like mandarins (which feed heavily on this size prey) would be inappropriate for reef tanks. As mentioned in the Live Rock section of this FAQ, the patience to allow a tank to cycle for 3-12 months prior to the addition of most fish (and any non-herbivore fish) may improve the stability of the tank in regards to hair algae. Although hair algae will normally bloom during this period, a compensating population of micrograzers will also bloom. Once the two come into balance, the normal routine of slowly adding additional life forms can commence.
Q: How do I treat a fish with ich in a reef tank?
A: From Craig Bingman:
- I don't know of any medication for the treatment of marine ich that is safe to use in a reef tank.
- A pair of Lysmata cleaner shrimp typically can make a large difference, even in cases where there is an ectoparasite explosion caused by an incoming fish.
- If there are recurring problems of this sort in a reef aquarium, the problem is almost certainly a symptom of an underlying system performance or fish health issue.
The first places to look are:
- excessive temperature swings
- low dissolved oxygen
- stagnant water conditions
- improper fish nutrition
Some fish that are cyanide-compromised may be too weak and internally damaged that there is little that can be done to help them.
The use of a quarantine tank is probably the best solution. A small 10 gallon tank with a heater, air-stone, and some live rock for filtration should suffice. If treatment of a new fish is required, it shouldbe moved to a similar, but live-rockless, hospital tank where medication can be administered. When doing a water change from your main tank, consider using any clean collected water as source water for your quarantine and hospital tanks. This will help acclimate your new purchases to the water parameters associated with their future home.